Selecting the right security entrance for your organisation is a critical decision that impacts everything from daily operations to overall security posture. While the choice might seem straightforward, various factors come into play when determining the most suitable option. This guide explores three primary types of security entrances—mantraps, speed gates, and turnstiles—to help you make an informed decision based on your specific business requirements.
Need Help Securing Your Business?
Get in touch today to see how we can help
Define Your Security Needs
Before evaluating specific solutions, it’s essential to understand your organisation’s unique requirements. The volume of daily foot traffic significantly influences your choice, as does the required security level. You’ll need to consider your available space, budget constraints, and how the entrance will integrate with your existing security solutions. The user experience is equally important—an overly complicated or slow system might encourage people to find ways around it, compromising your security.
Comparative overview:
| Feature | Mantraps | Speed Gates | Turnstiles |
|---|---|---|---|
| Security Level | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Speed of Access | ⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Aesthetics | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐ |
| Cost | High | Medium | Low |
| Ideal for | High-security areas | Offices, commercial buildings | Public spaces, stadiums |
Mantraps (Security Portals)
Mantraps, also known as security portals or interlocking door systems, represent the highest level of entrance security available. These systems consist of an enclosed space with two sets of doors that cannot be opened simultaneously, ensuring complete control over access.
Financial institutions often choose mantraps for their highest-security areas, such as vault access points or trading floors. Data centers and government facilities also frequently implement these systems, particularly in areas containing sensitive information or equipment. Research laboratories benefit from the additional environmental control these portals provide, as they can help maintain clean room conditions while ensuring security.
The primary advantage of mantraps lies in their unparalleled security. By allowing only one person through at a time, they effectively eliminate tailgating and piggybacking attempts. Many systems can integrate with advanced biometric verification methods, adding another layer of security. However, these benefits come with trade-offs. Mantraps significantly reduce throughput rates compared to other options, and their enclosed nature can cause anxiety in some users. They also require more physical space and generally represent the highest initial investment among security entrance options.
Speed Gates
Speed gates strike an elegant balance between security and efficiency, making them increasingly popular in modern commercial environments. These systems use rapidly moving barriers that quickly permit access for authorised individuals while maintaining a secure perimeter.
Corporate offices particularly favor speed gates for their main lobbies, as they combine a sophisticated appearance with efficient operation. Many technology companies and educational institutions have also adopted these systems, appreciating their ability to handle high traffic volumes while maintaining adequate security levels. Healthcare facilities often choose speed gates with wider lanes to accommodate equipment and wheelchair access.
The greatest strength of speed gates lies in their ability to process many people quickly without sacrificing security. Their modern appearance enhances building aesthetics, and their flexible configuration options allow for customisation to specific needs. However, they typically require more maintenance than simpler systems like turnstiles, and their initial cost can be substantial. While they provide good security, they don’t offer the same level of protection as mantraps.
Full-Height Turnstiles
Traditional turnstiles remain a reliable and cost-effective choice for many organisations. These time-tested systems excel in durability and simplicity, making them particularly suitable for high-traffic environments where basic access control is needed.
Sports venues and transportation hubs frequently deploy turnstiles due to their ability to handle large crowds efficiently. Manufacturing facilities often choose them for employee entrances, appreciating their durability and low maintenance requirements. Retail environments might use them to control access to employee areas or manage customer flow in certain situations.
The main advantages of turnstiles stem from their simplicity. They’re generally the most economical option, require minimal maintenance, and prove extremely reliable even in challenging conditions. Many models offer weather resistance for outdoor installation. However, their basic nature means they provide only fundamental security features and may not integrate as seamlessly with modern access control systems. Their utilitarian appearance might not suit more upscale environments.
Sector-Specific Considerations
Different industries face unique challenges that influence their choice of security entrance. Financial services prioritise high security, often implementing a combination of mantraps for sensitive areas and speed gates for general access.
Healthcare facilities need to balance security with accessibility, making wide-lane speed gates with emergency override capabilities an attractive option. Corporate offices typically focus on creating a professional first impression while maintaining smooth traffic flow, leading many to choose speed gates or high-end turnstiles.
| Industry | Best Security Entrance | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Finance & Data Centres | Mantraps (Security Portals) | High security for sensitive data. |
| Corporate Offices | Speed Gates | Combines security with seamless access. |
| Public Transport & Events | Turnstiles | Cost-effective, controls large crowds. |
| Government Buildings | Mantraps (Security Portals) | Strict access control required. |
| Retail & Shopping Malls | Speed Gates | Allows quick entry while preventing theft. |
| Gyms & Leisure Centres | Turnstiles | Self-service access for members. |
| Warehouses & Factories | Turnstiles or Speed Gates | Balances access control with employee movement. |
Manufacturing environments require particularly durable solutions that can withstand harsh conditions and heavy use. Retail and entertainment venues prioritise rapid throughput while maintaining basic security, often leading to multiple lanes of turnstiles or speed gates.
Making Your Final Decision
The selection process should begin with a thorough assessment of your security requirements and daily traffic patterns. Calculate the total cost of ownership, including maintenance and potential upgrades. Consider your available space carefully—installation requirements can significantly impact your options. Factor in your building’s aesthetic requirements and plan for future growth and system integration needs.
Once you’ve chosen a system, plan implementation carefully. Consider starting with a pilot program in one area before full deployment. Ensure thorough training for security staff and clear communication with employees about any new procedures. Professional installation and maintenance contracts can help ensure optimal performance and longevity.
Remember that the best solution might combine different entrance types for different areas of your facility. A corporate headquarters might use mantraps for server room access, speed gates in the main lobby, and turnstiles for the parking garage entrance. Working with a security consultant can help develop a comprehensive strategy that addresses all your organisation’s needs while staying within budget constraints.
- Mantraps (Security Portals): Best for high-security environments requiring strict access control.
- Speed Gates: Ideal for corporate offices and commercial spaces where security and efficiency must be balanced.
- Turnstiles: A cost-effective solution for high-traffic areas needing basic access control.
The right security entrance ultimately depends on finding the perfect balance between security requirements, operational efficiency, and user experience for your specific situation. By carefully considering all factors and understanding the strengths and limitations of each option, you can make an informed decision that serves your organisation well for years to come.